The One Big Beautiful Bill (OBBB) introduced new deductions and credits that directly impact the size of your refund. But as these tax rules become more complex, tax software services are quietly adjusting their pricing — and some tools that appear “free” are now anything but.

Here is the truth behind the TurboTax vs. FreeTaxUSA divide — especially when it comes to the new OBBB deduction calculations.

The OBBB Deductions: Why This Matters

The OBBB tax legislation introduced several new tax-reducing mechanisms, including:

• The Senior Deduction
• The Overtime Half-Time Deduction
• The Tip Deduction
• The Car Loan Interest Deduction
• The Working Families Deduction

These require:

• employer cross-matching
• Box 14 W-2 verification
• Schedule C net-income checks
• transcript-verified eligibility
• new data cross-references

This is no longer simple “enter your W-2 and done.”
These deductions require IRS-level logic — and that’s where the software differences begin.

TurboTax: More Automated, More Invasive — and More Expensive

TurboTax now charges higher-tier pricing for:

• Overtime deduction analysis
• Tip deduction eligibility
• Senior bonus validation
• Car loan interest requirements
• OBBB deduction worksheets
• Box 14 employer-reported verification

TurboTax relies heavily on automated question sequences and guided prompts.
But the tradeoff is cost.

TurboTax may push you into:

• Deluxe
• Premier
• Self-Employed
• Add-On Audit Defense
• “Live Assisted” Support

What starts as “Free to start” often becomes:

$60 → $120 → $179 → $249 very quickly.

FreeTaxUSA: Low Cost, but More Manual

FreeTaxUSA has a simpler interface with fewer guided OBBB-specific wizards.

Strengths:

• Extremely low cost
• Clear form-level entry
• Transparent upgrade pricing

Weaknesses:

• Less guidance
• More manual input
• More room for user error
• Fewer automated OBBB calculators

FreeTaxUSA relies on the taxpayer already knowing they qualify.

If you miss entering something — the software won’t notice.
If you’re eligible for a deduction — it won’t push you to claim it.
If something is wrong — it won’t warn you until after filing.

The Real Hidden Cost: Missed Deductions

When it comes to OBBB deductions, here is the danger:

TurboTax users pay more out-of-pocket.
FreeTaxUSA users risk losing hundreds or thousands in refund dollars.

Example:

A tipped restaurant worker qualifies for a $25,000 deduction.
TurboTax: Helps identify the deduction but charges $120+
FreeTaxUSA: May not detect eligibility — worker claims $0

Example:

A senior couple qualifies for $12,000 in deductions.
TurboTax: Software prompts to apply it correctly
FreeTaxUSA: If not manually entered — refund is wrong

Example:

An employee qualifies for the overtime premium deduction.
TurboTax: Reads employer Box 14 codes
FreeTaxUSA: Manual entry required; user must calculate themselves

Which One Actually Gets You a Bigger Refund?

TurboTax:
Likely to catch more OBBB-based deductions and generate a larger refund because of built-in logic.

FreeTaxUSA:
Likely cheaper — but relies on taxpayer knowledge to avoid missing benefits.

It’s a trade-off:

Who Should Use Which?

Use TurboTax if:

• you receive tips
• you work overtime
• you drive a new U.S.-assembled vehicle
• your employer uses W-2 Box 14 OBBB codes
• you are a senior claiming new deductions
• you file Schedule C
• you don’t fully understand OBBB rules

Use FreeTaxUSA if:

• your return is simple
• your income source is W-2 only
• you don’t claim OBBB deductions
• you know exactly what you are doing
• you manually track eligible tax benefits
• you want the lowest cost filing method

A Hidden Workaround: The Optimal Filing Strategy

Here’s a smart strategy:

1. Use TurboTax first to analyze your return
2. Write down the deductions it identifies
3. Stop before paying
4. Switch to FreeTaxUSA
5. Manually enter everything TurboTax helped you uncover

This technique:

• avoids upgrade fees
• uses TurboTax as a deduction-finder
• files using cheaper software
• keeps the full refund

OBBB introduced powerful refund-boosting deductions.
But the more complex the tax code becomes, the more software platforms profit from the confusion.

TurboTax charges more — but captures more benefits.
FreeTaxUSA costs less — but requires tax-savvy users.

If you don’t fully understand the new OBBB deduction requirements, TurboTax may be worth the cost.
If you know the law yourself, FreeTaxUSA can save real dollars.